UMBC’s familiar grounds and buildings take on a very different look when you are searching for a warm place to spend the night outdoors. In everyday life you think of the buildings as forums for the activities within: teaching and learning, eating and sleeping. But when the insides are off limits to you, they are simply structures: a wall that blocks the wind, a stairwell you might crouch behind without getting too muddy.
My companions and I are already tired, hungry and frustrated. We had spent a long day in Baltimore as a part of one of UMBC’s Alternative School Break programs. The two of them—Ryan Riehl and Al Volkening—had signed up for a week of intensive learning experiences relating to poverty and homelessness. On this day—Wednesday, March 18th—I had joined them for “poverty plunge”: a taste of what it would be like for newly homeless people trying to get by on Baltimore’s streets.
We had met at 7:30 a.m. in the lobby of Erickson Hall, Ryan and Al emerging with seven other students who had been spending nights camped out in a nearby lounge. Two hours later we were shivering together at a downtown bus stop, unprepared for a 40 degree wind chill on a day when the forecast had called for a toasty 68 degrees. Eventually we arrived at our destination north of Fells Point. The students were given roles to play: Ryan was a depressed, injured veteran unable to pay the rent after his mother died; Al a recovering meth addict just out of prison. Our instructions: stay within the designated 20-block area. Plan to spend no more than $2 apiece on food for the day. Develop plans for obtaining meals, shelter, medicine and jobs. Meet back at 3:00 p.m.
One day on the streets can't really convey the experience of being homeless. Ryan, Al and I had the enormous psychological advantage of knowing our situation was temporary. But after a few hours of fruitlessly searching for services and being turned away from churches, we were tired and lethargic, and I needed a place to go to the bathroom. That wouldn’t have been a problem if we had money to spend, but ubiquitous signs warning that restrooms were for “customers only” suggested that relieving our bladders would require emptying our wallets. Eventually we all found some useful services at a mental health clinic on Broadway (Ryan and Al interviewed a manager about their characters’ needs and I got to use the bathroom). Not long after that we pooled our $6 to purchase three bananas, a bag of tortillas and a jar of peanut butter from a corner market we had passed several times. We ate on an iron bench on the Broadway median strip.
Several very long hours later we were back on campus. The students eagerly returned to their lounge, looking forward to resting indoors, only to discover that their “shelter” had closed for the night. Each was given a “sandwich” consisting of a thin slice of lunch meat between two pieces of bread and told to search for a place to sleep. Ryan, Al and I stalked off in the direction of The Commons at around 7:00 p.m.
Along either side of Hilltop Circle between Administration Drive and Commons Drive runs a gulley that provides some shelter from the chilly wind. Here there are tunnels beneath the street with bright lights that provide a little warmth. One of the tunnels is full of water and muck, but another is dry, and we decide that is where we will spend the night if we must. In the last glimmering of daylight we head back toward the center of campus in search of cardboard to shield us from the cold concrete and metal. Other groups of wandering “homeless” have taken refuge in a Commons Garage stairwell, and are using newspapers as blankets and pillows.
My little band has reached the AOK Library and finally located a recycling bin when Kati Henry, the student coordinating this part of the ASB experience, calls my cell phone and asks us to separate and stop talking to each other. Ryan walks up a hill to the recycling bin, grabs a bag of paper scraps and huddles with it against the outer wall of the Library. Al stretches out on a bench next to the pond, then finds a warmer spot next to the glass wall of the Financial Aid Office. I lie on a nearby hillside, my head on my backpack, and shiver. I know that this last, lonely phase of the simulation will last only about 45 minutes, but Ryan and Al are literally and figuratively in the dark.
Half an hour later, I am huddled on the ground next to the Library when a female Financial Aid staff member I don’t know approaches the office door, gives me a concerned look, and rushes inside. Ten minutes later I’m pacing around for warmth when she emerges with a female colleague. I realize that they must be frightened to see a strange man hovering in the dark near the door, and try to reassure them by smiling and saying hello. Not surprisingly, the gesture seems to backfire: As someone who does not belong outside the Library at night, my actions can only be seen as menacing. The two of them walk quickly to a nearby car and get inside.
At that point time is up, and the simulation ends. I gather Ryan and Al for the quick walk back to Erickson Hall and a hot meal, all of us grateful to come in from the cold and conscious of the fact that many of the people whose experiences we had been seeking to understand would not have the same chance that night.
When I was in college, I would not have been willing to spend my spring break experiencing hardships and helping others. I’m very impressed by the dozens of UMBC students who did exactly that. Congratulations and thanks to Jordanna Spencer from the Office of Student Life and Sara Leidner from the Residential Life Office, who serve as the behind-the-scenes point people for the Alternative School Break programs, and to the administrators, staff and students who have made huge contributions to their success.
Update: If you're interested in another opportunity to learn from experience, check out the class I'll be teaching in the fall, which is described in my next post (here).
whoa...David, that's pretty amazing and it sounds like a harrowing experience. I just came back from leading an alternative break to New Orleans for rebuilding.
ReplyDeleteI lived out of a car all week but I was in Florida so I really can't complain a whole lot about that. =]
ReplyDelete@Ben: I'd love to hear--or read--about your experience.
ReplyDelete@Minteh: Always one step beyond! Welcome home.
David, thanks for sharing this incredible experience you chose to have.
ReplyDeleteIts very scary when you have to live like that. Or think you may have to. I never had to personally experience it, but I know people personally who have and I never truly empathized with homeless people until that moment I feared for the safety and well being of those I loved.
ReplyDeleteI applaud all of you for actually caring enough to at least attempt to understand and feel what they are feeling. Though it can only simulate it, that's still a learning experience that really says something about your personality :).
This sounds absolutely amazing. I wish I could have been a part of something so profound during my spring break. I hope my work with the homeless through my internship this summer reveals to me the ways I can cause greater changes in society.
ReplyDelete@everyone: Thanks so much for your comments. A simulation like the one I experienced is great for building understanding and empathy for people who are experiencing hardships. I hope you can find ways to have similar experiences. But I also think there's a danger of coming away with a sense of futility: that the problems are so great that it's impossible to do anything about them. I appreciate lovesintheeyre's attitude: find a way to taste the gritty reality, but use the experience as a springboard to involvement in social change!
ReplyDeleteIt seems to me that UMBC is a pretty welcoming place to the homeless and those trying to temporarily spend the night, if they know what buildings are open. There are 2 large climate-controlled 24-hour spaces available on campus, the engineering building and the library atrium. I guess these weren't allowed in your simulation, but I've sometimes seen "regulars" in these locations. And in the city Helping Up Mission offers a bed to sleep on, hot shower, and hot meal (or 2) for $2 per night- free the first night, if you get in line soon enough.
ReplyDeleteThese aren't ideal options, and I've never had to use them myself. I wish I would've done an Urban Plunge ASB this Spring Break to get a real experience of poverty.
What an amazing experience... I really love the idea and would love to try it some time, since you cannot really feel what the real homeless feels until you go through it. I usually look at their problems to be related to just having enough food and a warm place to spend the night, but never though about the other details like finding a restroom or taking a shower...etc.
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your story with us.
@ minteh: yeah that car was pretty awesome... ya know except for the "drivers' side marker light constantly falling out" part ;)
ReplyDeleteWhat would be interesting is if you could get a netbook (or something similar) into the hands of a real homeless person to blog about their experience.
ReplyDelete@ Mike G
ReplyDeleteI was thinking that too. I know there are regulars that come to the UMBC library sometimes to wash up, get a hot coffee, and spend the night reading or something at one of the tables.
Also there are a lot of places in the city (like Red Emma's Bookstore Coffeehouse) that offer free use of restrooms, internet, etc., and often discounted prices on tea or bagels or whatever as a service to those who are homeless.
Knowing where to look is the difficult part.
This is just ridiculous. Typical college students "pretending to be homesless." You could of interviewed actual homeless people, those people that are actually homeless instead of pretending to be homeless with your friends and writing about as if your doing some great justice for the UMBC community. How about you and your friends do something more than just pretend? Don't you thing your a little to old for pretend?
ReplyDeleteThis was the most selfish disgusting article I have ever read!
Your way too old for pretend. How about discussing the larger societal theme of homelessness in America. Possibly, the fact that we live in one of the most developed and advanced countries in the world, yet we ironically still have people that live and sleep on the streets of our major cities.
ReplyDeleteCollege will never teach you common sense, and apparently this simulation did not happen in the heart of Baltimore City. Fells Point is where college kids go to get drunk not where homeless people sleep. Spend the night in Druid Park- write an article about your experience there. You might encounter the true homeless expereince. People there smoke crack and shoot heroin, but your probably too scared to find out what some homeless people spend your money on.
Not all homeless people do drugs, many are in fact mentally ill or people that have had terrible things happen in their lives.
You need to get back to being homeless so you can find the true meaning of the word. You need to get a reality check and your friends are no better than you.
You should be ashamed of pretending to be homeless.
Do you still play house with your friends?
Wow!! They let you teach a class at UMBC. This is awful.
ReplyDeleteGo figure another professor at UMBC with absolutely no life expereience outside a classroom. Theory and B.S. What do people learn from you writing this?
ReplyDeleteThe fact that everything you ever did in your life was just pretend. Next time write about your last three jobs outside ACADEMIA!!!!
If it was not for ACADEMIA you would be homeless
ReplyDeleteNow, I know why our country is in shambles, because people like you are teaching the next generation to think like a total idiot.
ReplyDeleteThe posts are encouraging your absurd behavior. College students mention internet access at a local coffee shop.
When was the last time you saw a homeless person with a laptop. College is supposed to get people to think. How are these students ever going to live in the "real world." And I'm not talking about the show on MTV. The world we live in..............
I would not be proud of being "homeless for a day."
ReplyDelete@Alex/Anonymous of the seven comments left between 11:14 and 11:55 p.m. last night: For the students who participated in the homelessness simulation, this was just one day out of a week spent learning about the experience of poverty in Baltimore. The week's other activities were focused on connecting with people such as the men at the Helping Up Mission (see community.helpingupmission.org)--people experiencing hardships who shared their stories. The one-day simulation was a way of gaining some insights, not a substitute for other approaches to learning about homelessness.
ReplyDeleteThe students and faculty who went through this experience for the day were NEVER under the impression that they even came close to experiencing what a person who is actually homeless experiences on a day-to-day basis. The simulation was not meant to "pretend to be homeless" -- it was meant to provide the participants with an opportunity to see how spending an entire day out in the cold, with no idea where to go for help, and with very little or no money can affect you in just a matter of hours. In short, it did affect them, and helped them become a little more sensitive to what someone who is homeless might go through EVERY SINGLE DAY. The people one the trip went through something that is 1/1000th as hard as the people actually experiencing homelessness do, and it was still very demoralizing and hard at times. That is pretty powerful in itself.
ReplyDeleteIt's easy to read about something and think you understand it. This trip has given people who were very educated about homelessness beforehand a chance to deepen their empathy and understanding. It's not about pretending, it's about trying to understand as much as you can.
and just for the record, we weren't in fells point, we were north of it. this was done because the university wanted to make sure students would only be in safe areas of the city. had the planners or students on the trip had their way, we would have gone somewhere else.
ReplyDeleteTo Anonymous, the rest of the week WAS filled with discussions about the larger issues of homelessness and poverty. This was one day of the six-day trip.
Sounds like an excuse to get out of doing anything productive for the week. Note to self: Don't take any of this joker's classes.
ReplyDeleteIn response to Kati's comments, everything you are saying should have been clarified in the article that described the homeless trip UMBC students took to Baltimore.
ReplyDeleteYou want to talk about empathy?
I do not believe you understand the true meaning of the word.
How can anyone from college truly understand the feelings and emotions of a homeless person, from one day spent pretending to be homeless?
Maybe you need to spend a year on the streets being homeless. The fact that many homeless women turn tricks and become prostitutues, as they have no other options.
Do not talk about empathy, what you are describing is sympathy, there is a major difference.
Grow up and quit acting like you know everything about homelessness in America.
Admit that you have no idea what a terrible experience and feeling it would be to find out you have no place to go but the streets.
Just appreciate how good your life is compared to so many unfortunate people that have no bed or family to fall-back on.
To Anonymous, the rest of the week WAS filled with discussions about the larger issues of homelessness and poverty. This was one day of the six-day trip.
ReplyDeleteThe fact that the rest of the week was filled with discussions speaks for itself. That is what you wrote
ALL TALK AND NO ACTION_TYPICAL
You all are extrememly selfish individuals!
ReplyDeleteI am involved with organizations to actually help homeless people. The time spent pretending could have spent acting on these issues.
ReplyDeleteI have encouraged people to volunteer to help homeless people get off the streets.
Time spent pretending is time that could have been spent helping.
If you understand this much-realize what this professor did was wrong and all the students who participated in this part of the event or week were doing nothing but making a mochary of people who do not have a home.
I'm sure the heroin and bottles of wine help with sleeping. Also, the person above me tried to sound smart, but the misspelled mockery. What is a 'mochary'?
ReplyDelete@ Anonymous with better plans:
ReplyDeleteIn order to get more people aware and interested in helping the homeless and impoverished, they need to at least have sympathy for the poor. If you have better ideas for how to spread awareness of the situations of the poor I think it would be great to sit down and talk about how to make future trips, breaks, etc better. It's definitely impossible for someone to fully understand the desperation of a prostitute or a drug addict without being in their shoes. But conversations with people at places like tent city and helping up can spur people towards meaningful change. For a while I've wanted to make pamphlets for the homeless of Baltimore detailing resources in the city where they can get help with issues of food, medical, education, housing, etc. It sounds like some people on here could help me? Or might be interested?
FYI: a group of us take weekly trips to Helping Up to support the men and serve food. If you come for the first time, I'll make sure that someone can come and talk to us about their addictions and previous life, and how they've been changed by God and the people at Helping Up. E-mail me at migerman1@gmail.com .
People do in fact misspell words.
ReplyDeleteI knew someone would mention a typing error or a misspelled word to avoid talking about the real subject, which is this B.S. story.
@ anonymous
ReplyDeleteInfused throughout our whole day was the understanding that we could never possibly understand the true reality of homelessness from spending a few hours doing what we did. While your suggestion that we spend a year on the streets being homeless is interesting, it's not very feasbile, nor would that allow us to help the people who are actually homeless, which we spent the rest of the week doing.
You said, "Admit that you have no idea what a terrible experience and feeling it would be to find out you have no place to go but the streets.
Just appreciate how good your life is compared to so many unfortunate people that have no bed or family to fall-back on." I could not have said it better. Having students realize what you said in your post was a major point of the trip. If you have any more ideas, definitely let me know. It sounds like you'd be great at planning a better trip next year.